“One of Us is Lying”: Recommendation or Denunciation? I n this blog post, I will be discussing “ One of Us is Lying ” by Karen M. McManus. “ One of Us is Lying ” is a high school murder mystery centered on the mysterious death of Simon (the outcast) in a detention room with four other students. These five other students include Bronwyn (a Yale Bound rule-abiding student), Addy (the beauty or homecoming queen), Nate (the criminal already on probation), and Cooper (the athlete/all star baseball pitcher). One of us is lying, takes readers through the student’s inner secrets and challenges the reader to figure out who’s lying before the end. I first read this book two years ago, and I was pretty disappointed. Prior to reading it, I read many reviews and book blogs (similar to our classes) hyping up the book as a huge, mind blowing, revolutionary murder mystery. However, predictable is the only thing I would call this book. To me, the culprit was pretty obvious from the beginnin...